top of page
  • Writer's pictureMarie Mullany

The Rule of Darkness: In defense of the Evil Overlord



In the annals of fantasy, the Evil Overlord Trope requires little introduction. They are the embodiment of wickedness and terror, ruling over a kingdom of despair with an iron fist. Think fire and brimstone, darkness, and inhospitable lands. The Evil Overlord usually resides in a realm that mirrors their nefarious intentions, a nest teeming with their minions and loyal followers. With ambitions typically bent on world domination, they are not your typical villains - they are not just the bad guys, they are evil incarnate. Today, let's delve into this sometimes maligned but often intriguing trope, and see why it deserves a robust defense.


The Virtues of the Evil Overlord

A Clear Antagonistic Force The Evil Overlord trope provides a clear antagonistic force in a story. They are the embodiment of darkness against which the forces of good must struggle, providing a clear delineation between good and evil that is essential in many fantasy narratives.

Example: In J.R.R. Tolkien's "Lord of the Rings," Sauron, the Dark Lord, embodies this role perfectly. His desire to dominate all of Middle-Earth provides the driving force for the entire trilogy. His presence, although mostly felt rather than seen, creates an unambiguous enemy that unites the disparate free peoples of Middle-Earth against him.


The Monumental Challenge An Evil Overlord usually possesses immense power, posing a nearly insurmountable challenge for the protagonists. This ups the stakes and provides a sense of scale and awe in the narrative, increasing tension and the satisfaction of eventual victory.

Example: In Rick Riordan's "Percy Jackson & the Olympians" series, the primordial titan Chronos poses a formidable challenge. Not only is he the literal embodiment of time, but he also carries a personal vendetta against the gods of Olympus and their demigod children. His eventual rise and the looming threat it presents elevates the stakes of the series, making his defeat a monumental challenge. The protagonists must scramble to gather allies and resources in order to combat this seemingly insurmountable threat. Percy Jackson, our young demigod protagonist, must not only grapple with his own identity but also face the colossal task of opposing Chronos, thus reinforcing the narrative tension and making the victory all the more satisfying when it comes.

Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

While the Evil Overlord is a powerful narrative device, there are potential pitfalls that can diminish their effectiveness in a story.


The Monolithic Evil An Evil Overlord can sometimes appear as a one-dimensional figure of pure evil without any depth or complexity. This can make them less interesting and their motivations less compelling.

Pitfall example: Sauron, from "The Lord of the Rings," although a formidable enemy, is somewhat monolithic and impersonal. We never get to know him beyond his desire to dominate all life.

How to avoid: Give your Evil Overlord a backstory and motivations that explain their path to darkness. They don't have to be sympathetic, but they should be understandable.


The Invincible Overlord An Overlord who seems utterly invincible can lower the stakes of a story. If they are too powerful, it might be hard for the audience to believe in the possibility of their defeat.

Pitfall example: In the "Sword of Truth" series by Terry Goodkind, the evil emperor Jagang appears invincible at times, making it hard to believe in his potential defeat.

How to avoid: Balance your Evil Overlord's power with limitations or vulnerabilities that can be exploited, giving the protagonists a believable chance to triumph.

(Do not use Deux Ex. Do not follow Goodkind's example).


The Absent Overlord An Evil Overlord who is often absent from the story can lose their menacing effect, as they start to feel distant and less threatening.

Pitfall example: In "A Song of Ice and Fire" series by George R. R. Martin, the Night King is a major threat looming in the background, yet he is often absent from the narrative for extended periods of time. This absence, especially in the earlier books, can occasionally make him feel less immediate and threatening despite the impending danger he represents.

How to avoid: To maintain the menacing presence of your Evil Overlord, ensure that their influence and actions are continuously felt throughout the narrative. This could be through the consequences of their past actions, their minions actively working towards their goals, or through the pervasive fear and respect other characters in the story have for them. Even if they're not directly present, they should still cast a long shadow over the story.




In defense of the Evil Overlord, it's not the trope itself, but the execution that makes or breaks the story. When crafted with care, an Evil Overlord can bring a sense of epic scale, high stakes, and clear conflict to your fantasy narrative. They can be more than just a figure of pure evil—they can be a monument to the struggle against darkness and the power of resilience.


Happy writing! And remember, we all get better one word at a time.


Enjoyed this blog? Feel free to show your appreciation on my ko-fi page. Every little helps keep the darkness at bay.










3 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page